CLM-0012 — Say and they-said each occur 332 times
DOES_NOT_HOLD_UNDER_DECLARED_RULES Audit report · deterministic reproduction
1 · Claim as commonly stated
Qul and qalu each occur exactly 332 times.
Source note: Widely circulated in numerical-miracle literature and popular media; earliest precise source unverified, attribution left open rather than guessed.
2 · Reproduction method
Declared counting-rule matrix, executed against corpus quran:hafs-kufan:v1. Full rules, counts, and sample locations: EXP-0008.
3 · Result
Not reproduced under the declared bare-surface rule (qul: surface 298, lemma 0, root 0; qalu: surface 250, lemma 0, root 0); the popular figure requires counting clitic-attached variants (فقل, وقالوا…), a rule the claim never states.
4 · Sensitivity to counting rules
DOES_NOT_HOLD_UNDER_DECLARED_RULES.
5 · Statistical context
STATISTICALLY_UNASSESSED — no preregistered null exists for 'a declared rule lands on a meaningful number'; constructing one after seeing the result would be circular.
6 · Best argument in favor
With clitic-attached forms included the totals move toward the popular figure.
7 · Strongest objection
The claim is stated about two bare forms; the declared bare-surface rule gives 298 vs 250.
8 · All recorded objections
- The claim is stated about two bare forms; the declared bare-surface rule gives 298 vs 250.
- With thousands of countable properties and free choice of counting rule, exact matches are expected somewhere by chance alone; only rules declared before counting carry weight.
9 · Final status
DOES_NOT_HOLD_UNDER_DECLARED_RULES
10 · Public summary
Not reproduced under the declared bare-surface rule (qul: surface 298, lemma 0, root 0; qalu: surface 250, lemma 0, root 0); the popular figure requires counting clitic-attached variants (فقل, وقالوا…), a rule the claim never states..
11 · Reproduce it yourself
python3 services/research-worker/scripts/run_experiment.py data/research/specs/EXP-0008.json — the registry entry lives in data/research/claims.json; the result files record input checksums and environment.